While reading through Ladybugs, Tornadoes, and Swirling Galaxies, I couldn’t help but think these ELL students in 1st grade reminded me an awful lot of my native English speaking Pre-K students. It wasn’t the lack of language or abilities that reminded me of my students, but the engagement with their world and making meaning out of writing and reading for themselves. I often have to explain to people that there is quite A LOT of learning that goes on inside a Pre-K classroom, despite what they may think. Learning all about Brad and Anne’s classroom, all I could think is, “wow! they are doing SO MUCH!” And that’s exactly how I feel about my classroom. I look around my room sometimes, and if I didn’t know any better--it looks like complete chaos. But I do know better. I know that my students are engaging in their environment and more importantly, they are socializing with their peers and learning so much about their world and how to work with others. They’re most definitely learning from each other, even if they don’t know it yet. What I found so fascinating about Brad and Anne’s classroom is how they intentionally let the children know that they are in a classroom with their peers to learn from them, to connect and construct ideas together, and to support and encourage each other’s work.
One of the most beautiful things about their classroom that really resonates with me and how I operate in my own classroom is how they have developed a trusting relationship with their students. They mentioned that early on they used to be concerned with what they other children were doing while they were conferring with a student or working one-on-one with a student who really needed that specific time with the teacher. They later decided to let go this need to control and keep up with what every child is doing in the classroom and instead place some accountability on their students to focus and engage themselves in topics that they want to read, write, or learn more about. I know this is how I used to be when I first started teaching. I wanted to make sure that EVERY minute of my students’ day was filled with meaningful activities. I slowly, but surely found out that that way of operating is nearly impossible. One single person cannot make sure that all students are on task all the time. And in some ways, I feel that it is enabling a child to constantly stand over their shoulder and keep tabs on what they are doing. Now I feel that I have more freedom to work with different students on days that they need my help with a project they are working on.
”Valid text is generated by the kids through their writing. we read it aloud, we read it together, and we read it independently. reading is a big piece of inquiry, yet we place a heavy focus on gathering, categorizing, and organizing information through the inquiry process” (Buhrow and Garcia, 2006, p. )
This quote really made me think a lot about how I view my student’s writing. In the book, Brad and Anne always make a big deal about the children’s writing and reading of their own material. And they should make a big deal out of it because it is a big deal! I love when my kids write words on their drawings, or even when they use felt animals or story rocks to tell a story and we record their story in their journal or on another peice of paper. However, I have a really hard time coming back to their writing and celebrating it and making a big deal out of it with the rest of the class. I think it’s important to build confidence in young children for their writing accomplishments, but it’s also important to encourage the efforts they are making. Even with some of my students, I’m genuinly amazing at how well their retention is of a certain text we read and come back to that text and make it their own in a new way. In this way, I think they are using these inquiry skills we are constantly talking about building in our students. They are putting together the texts we are reading in class with how that actually relates to themselves.
“We noticed that when we left the kids’ writing and thinking up and out on tables, their energy to write and read grew. When kids are able to see other writers’ thinking, writing, editing, and rewriting, they notice and learn from each other through the writing process” (Buhrow and Garcia, 2006, p. ).


For me and my classroom, the most important thing I think my students can feel is ownership. Brad and Anne mention in their book that ownership is huge for young children. Feeling like they have something, that is their own and that they were the ones to come up with them. At the end of the day, I want my students to feel like their education and their choices are wholly theirs. I know we have to model and support this idea. But the goal should never be to control their output and input of knowledge, but rather to see where they take it and encourage and scaffold as much as we can along the way.
As a fellow Pre-K teacher, I found myself thinking the same thing you mentioned about the importance of the connection between the 4 year olds’ worlds and making meaning out of the writing and reading done in the classroom. I love what you said about you knowing that your students are engaging in their environment and learning how to work with others. Pre-K is such a different grade than any other because of it’s seemed lack of rigid structure, but what people need to remember is that a huge part of Pre-K is the students just learning how to be a part of society as a student and just a good human being! I join you in your fascination about Brad and Anne’s practice of purposefully letting the children know that they are in a classroom to learn from and work alongside each other and that it’s not a fend for yourself to get to the top sort of structure.
ReplyDeleteI applaud you on developing a class of students that have trusting relationships with each other. This is a hard thing to do with such a large group of students. I also liked reading about your connection to Brad and Anne’s release of constant control over all the students and intrusting in them more to be independent. Building a sense of independence will in turn build confidence – a skill that is important for little ones to acquire.
I loved seeing your students’ artwork and like how you connected it all to the reading. I feel you on your wanting to save a student’s work that they don’t want to part with – I like your idea of making a copy to put up and taking the time to talk to the student about why you are doing this. I can tell from your blog that you are very thoughtful and tedious in your decisions regarding your classroom’s learning environment and I think that’s amazing! Keep up the great work!
Hi Lindsey,
ReplyDeleteThe connection with the students cannot be overemphasized; this is invaluable in the classroom. “We noticed that when we left the kids’ writing and thinking up and out on tables, their energy to write and read grew. When kids are able to see other writers’ thinking, writing, editing, and rewriting, they notice and learn from each other through the writing process” (Buhrow and Garcia, 2006, p. ). I also identified with this quote. Children learn from each other. More importantly, displaying the work of the child builds confidence , passion, and OWNERSHIP. I love how your classroom displays the work of the students. This is something that I plan on doing myself.
Lindsey it appears that you have a great classroom culture set up for your kids. I can also feel the passion you have for teaching. It's always refreshing to see this. Continue the work of developing independent and critical thinkers in your classroom by continuing to model excellence.
Hi Lindsey!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your open and honest observations. I always enjoy reading your blog post because I am able to get a peek into your exciting classroom. I also enjoyed getting a peek into Brad and Anne's classroom was also exciting and very informative.
I squared with your idea that it is important to have constant engagement in the classroom and lessons that keeps the students active and excited (even if it looks like chaos). What I never considered was your point about, "they’re most definitely learning from each other, even if they don’t know it yet. What I found so fascinating about Brad and Anne’s classroom is how they intentionally let the children know that they are in a classroom with their peers to learn from them, to connect and construct ideas together, and to support and encourage each other’s work." While I make sure that students help each other I have never explained how peer mentoring helps the entire class develop and we can learn and grow from one another. I would like to develop that in my classroom and if you have any tips let me know!
I also think that it is great you are pushing your students to become inquiries. I am doing the same in my classroom and it is excellent when I see my students making connections and pointing out that they are inquirers. Keep up the good work! It sounds like you are doing a lot of great things in your classroom and making a lot of good connections.
Great job!
Kyla
Your classroom sounds like such an amazing place full of activity and inspiration! I know that feeling you describe of wanting every single moment of your kids' day chock full of meaningful activity; what a relief it must be to let go of control and step back and let them take the lead! It sounds like it comes pretty naturally for you! And your students sound amazing. Sure, we can't be breathing down their necks and keeping them on track every single second, but even those off-track moments can be valuable social practice, and it seems like you really recognize and embrace that. I think it is so cool that your classroom is mainly decorated by the student's work. It must be so rewarding for them to see their words and pictures up on the walls and treated as products of merit! Obviously you have great instincts and would fit in well in Brad and Anne's classroom :) I think photocopying their work and finding ways to help document sounds like a good idea. In the book, they emphasize holding on to such records so that progress can be easily monitored. You and I both really need to figure out how to practice that and stay organized so that the data is actually useful! Sounds to me like your kids are well on their way to becoming inquisitive, learning-loving, thinkers! They are so lucky to have a passionate teacher like you to guide them!
ReplyDeleteLindsey,
ReplyDeleteYour classroom sounds amazing! It is all to often that I, too, look around my classroom and think, " this is SO chaotic" and wonder if I have control. However, I loved how you talked about the fact that, that "chaotic" environment isn't chaos at all, but, rather an environment where students are engaging and learning so much! The opportunity for students to engage and discuss their ideas is so important and ultimately grows them as learners in ways that we can never even imagine.
I think it is so interesting at the end of your post when you talked about students taking ownership of the classroom. I love the idea that the classroom can be a place where students can come and share what they may have in mind and how you, as the teacher, can use it in your teaching. Your writing encouraged me to be more in line with creating an place that is "wholly for the students."
What a blessing it is for your students to have you as a teacher!
Christian
You've got enough comments you over preparer. :) Just kidding, I love your blog, and everyone has said what I wanted to say, and no this is not counting towards my three, but I wanted to let you know that I read it. :)
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing, Lindsey! Your blog is not only eloquently written, but also I thought that all of the connections that you made were so thoughtful. From your description of your efforts to make sure that your students feel a sense of ownership in the classroom and that they are encouraged to make their own decisions independently in addition to the care and detail that you clearly take to pay attention to your students' written pieces, it is clear to me that while on many levels you may be a natural teacher, you are also internalizing and adapting many of the texts to apply to your own teaching, which is great!
ReplyDeleteIt is clear from your blog that you are a teacher who cares deeply for her students and works her hardest to ensure that they feel comfortable and supported at all times. Well done! I surely will look at your classroom as an example for how to more effectively manage my own classroom as well :) Thanks again for sharing!